Drills used for establishing spring wheat: power harrow combination drill, minimum tillage Vaderstad drill, & Ecodyn direct drill

Performance of UK organic spring wheat and contrasting soil tillage: yield and economic impact

Author(s): 
Vijaya Bhaskar, AV, Cannon, ND & Davies, WP
Funders: 
The John Oldacre Foundation
Organisation: 
Royal Agricultural University
Copyright: 
Creative Commons Licence
Evidence: 
Academic research
Related theme: 
Buildings & machinery
Type, texture & structure
Compaction & cultivation
Cereals, oil seeds & pulses
Weeds

Download the PDF
Resource explained: 

Conventional tillage can be damaging to soil structure and quality. Non-inversion tillage techniques which minimise disruption to soil structure can save you time with seedbed preparation, increase soil organic matter, and reduce your operation costs. This poster outlines results from a study conducted at the Royal Agricultural University’s (RAU) organic Harnhill Manor Farm that looked at the effects of tillage (under organic management systems) on weeds, crop performance, gross margins and benefit cost ratios. Conventional tillage (CT) was compared with low residue non-inversion tillage (LRNiT) and high residue non-inversion tillage (HRNiT).

Findings & recommendations: 
  • The study ran from March 2012 to August 2013. Spring wheat cv. Paragon was drilled in March 2012. After harvesting in August 2012, soil cover was left on the field over winter, and the tillage process was repeated and spring wheat drilled in April 2013 and harvested in August.
  • The lowest weed dry matter (DM) and the most favourable seedbed conditions for wheat establishment (in both seasons) was recorded for the CT plots. This is attributed to reduced tillage seedbeds tending to be coarser and less uniform, with larger soil clods; this affects seed-soil contact or drill performance, and results in lower crop establishment.
  • The crop yields were largest when the crop establishment levels were the highest and the weed infestation levels were the lowest.
  • The study found that non-inversion tillage incurred lower production/variable costs. However, a substantial reduction in yield led to a significantly lower gross margin, compared to CT. The calculated overall value (or ‘benefit cost ratio’) was also significantly lower with non-inversion tillage.
  • In this study, the best results in relation to crop emergence, level of weeds and wheat yields, were obtained with CT.

(Header image: Drills used for establishing spring wheat: power harrow combination drill, minimum tillage Vaderstad drill, & Ecodyn direct drill. Photo credit: RAU)

Also see ‘Contrasting soil tillage effects on UK organic spring wheat.’

More about the organisation

Royal Agricultural University

partner Established in 1845, the Royal Agricultural University in Cirencester has a long-standing, global reputation for teaching and research in the agricultural and related land-based sector. Today, the university has a vibrant, forward-thinking, international community. Currently there are more than 1,200 students from over 45 different countries studying at the historic campus, set in 25 acres of magnificent grounds in the heart of the Cotswolds. The Royal Agricultural University maintains consistently high levels of graduate employability. Over the past five years, 96% of undergraduates have entered employment or further study within six months, with 80% securing professional or managerial roles. 

You may also be interested in

Minimum tillage established spring wheat on the left and plough power harrow established spring wheat on the right 2012

Tillage & undersowing effects on organic wheat yield components & yield

resource Royal Agricultural University RAU research providing insights into impacts of tillage and undersown crops on winter and spring wheat.
People & skills, Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Cereals, oil seeds & pulses, Grasslands & forage crops, Weeds
Drills establishing spring wheat: power harrow combination drill, Minimum tillage Vaderstad drill, Ecodyn direct drill

Contrasting soil tillage effects on UK organic spring wheat

resource Royal Agricultural University RAU research providing insights into effects of different levels of tillage on soil density, weeds, and wheat yields.
Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Drainage, Cereals, oil seeds & pulses, Crop nutrition & fertility building, Weeds
Drills for establishing spring wheat; power harrow combination drill, minimum tillage Vaderstad drill, Ecodyn direct drill

Characterisation of soil quality following conventional & non-inversion tillage

resource Royal Agricultural University Interesting research from the RAU exploring the effects of different forms of tillage on soil chemical and biological properties.
People & skills, Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Cereals, oil seeds & pulses, Grasslands & forage crops
Undersown white clover establishing in spring wheat

Investigation of suitable legume species for undersowing in organic spring wheat

resource Royal Agricultural University Some insights from the RAU on research carried out looking at the influence of different undersown legumes on wheat growth.
People & skills, Cereals, oil seeds & pulses, Grasslands & forage crops, Crop nutrition & fertility building, Weeds

Healthy Grassland Soils pocketbook

resource Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB) / EBLEX / DairyCo A practical guide giving pictorial advice on assessing, maintaining and improving grassland soil structure and soil biology levels.
Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Organic matter, Soil biology, Weeds, Grasslands & forage crops, Crop nutrition & fertility building, Business management, Buildings & machinery

Reduced tillage trials aim to improve soil sustainability

resource University of East Anglia / Wensum Alliance Interesting results from a 5-year reduced cultivation trial that took place at the Salle Park Estate, Norfolk, to assess the impact of contrasting tillage regimes...
Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Drainage, Organic matter, Soil biology, Cereals, oil seeds & pulses, Crop nutrition & fertility building, Buildings & machinery, People & skills, Pollinators & ecological services
Three rows of wheat followed by three rows of beans

Bi-cropping spring field bean (Vicia faba) and wheat (Triticum aestivum)

resource Royal Agricultural University RAU research looking at the effects of intercropping beans and wheat in relation to ecosystem services and forage production.
Cereals, oil seeds & pulses, Grasslands & forage crops, Crop nutrition & fertility building

Great Soils: Soil management for horticulture

resource AHDB Horticulture Good soil management can save you time and money. This leaflet gives you a practical overview of what to do.
Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Drainage, Organic matter, Cereals, oil seeds & pulses, Roots & horticulture

Fallowing in organic systems - a last resort?

resource Garden Organic A leaflet looking at the pros and cons of leaving land fallow in organic systems to help manage weeds,
Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Soil biology, Weeds, People & skills

No-till for growers: Part 2 - Soil health practices for growers

resource Organic Growers Alliance Part two of two detailed informal articles looking at the practicalities of applying a no-till system in an organic horticultural operation and how it relates...
Type, texture & structure, Compaction & cultivation, Rotations, Organic matter, Soil biology, Weeds